Download Citation on ResearchGate | Alcibíades según Platón | El objetivo de estas páginas es intentar deducir la personalidad de Alcibíades. Auto-conocimiento en el Alcibíades I, la Apología de Sócrates y el Teeteto: los límites Además argumentamos que, para Platón, este conocimiento no se logra. ALCIBIADES [PLATON] on *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers.

Author: Tygorr Gutilar
Country: Sweden
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Life
Published (Last): 19 October 2009
Pages: 80
PDF File Size: 5.73 Mb
ePub File Size: 20.79 Mb
ISBN: 841-9-16062-834-1
Downloads: 15074
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Mazulkis

The historical Alcibiades was the. He initially saw in Socrates the path to achieve political greatness, and the Platonic Alcibiades explains that this hope was unfounded: Hackett,v, — Apology tells the jury how his daemon prevented him from entering public life ; had he done so, he would long ago have perished, to the advantage of no one.

Athens achieved an important naval victory at Arginousai, but the navy is not in great shape after the battle. For Polus, tyranny means “the power of doing whatever seems good to you in a state, killing, banishing, doing all the things you like” c. It is meant to show that Socrates did not corrupt Alcibiades and Critias, and Xenophon insisted that while they were with Socrates the two behaved well.

Ithaca — London, Cornell University Press, There remains the problem of Callicles’ name. Brock, “Plato and comedy”, in “Owls to Athens”: Vickers, “Alcibiades on stage: In both places Alcibiades is closely associated with Callicles, but does not take part in the action.


Stallbaum, Platonis Gorgias, 3rd edn. If Critias is indeed in question, there may be a reference here to the incident which brought about a breach between him and Socrates.

Callicles’ comments are ironic: The most outstanding example in terms of the numbers involved was the judicial massacre of Eleusinians in order to create a bolt-hole at Eleusis for the Thirty. You can help Wikipedia by expanding it.

But whatever one makes of this suggestion, Alcibiades Minor confirms that things have soured between Socrates and Alcibiades. Lewisand Theramenes was in effect put to death at Critias’ bidding, and this passage gives the essence of what occurred. This deliberation is platoon only debate of the Athenian assembly recorded in the Hellenika. Again, this is an Alcibiadean, not a Socratic, failing.


Corrupting the Youth: Xenophon and Plato on Socrates and Alcibiades

Callicles is so carefully delineated that it is alcibjades to believe that he is wholly fictitious and if he were, he would be the only such example in the whole of Plato.

Hornblower, A Commentary on Thucy aides 1 Oxford, Ostensibly, the second Alcibiades concerns how one ought to pray, but Socrates seems above all interested in slowing Alcibiades down. But this story shows precisely the opposite, albeit perhaps somewhat delicately. Indianapolis, Hackett Publishing Company, Inc. Socrates, no longer the pursuer, expresses a fear that Alcibiades will become quite corrupt, and the dialogue ends with an ill omen of stormy seas ahead for Socrates Alc.

Davies remarks that “if Kritias Plaaton had in fact gained these alibiades victories there would have been some unmistakable echo of them in the literary tradition”.

Or, at least, it deters generals from making daring decisions that might skirt the rules of ordinary propriety or piety, decisions that might often be necessary in military matters. Critias’ relations with Alcibiades seem to have been friendly until late in both their lives.

Critias’ devotion to chariot-racing is, it is true, less well-known than that of Alcibiades, but evidence exists in the form of IG I3an inscribed statue-base dedicated to the Twelve Gods, but found in Salamis and subsequently lostrather than near the Altar in the Athenian Agora.

To refer directly to Alcibiades in Gorgias would have descended to the level of pamphleteering ; Plato wanted to write something more than that. Alcibiades demonstrates disrespect for the political and familial authority that Pericles represents, and argues forcefully against treating the democratic laws of Athens with respect. Elsewhere we hear of Alcibiades beating one of plafon followers to death with a club in a palaestra: With this Socrates proves that he is the only true lover of Alcibiades.

It seems possible, however, that the Protagoras comes between the two dialogues platn for Alcibiades. On Polycrates aldibiades general, alcibjades A. Plato’s “fine satire” [article] Michael Vickers. Put on trial before the Boule, Theramenes won the sympathy of most present, but “Critias, fearing that Theramenes might dissolve the oligarchy, surrounded him with soldiers carrying drawn swords.


Dodds, however, printed the true Pindaric text, arguing that “the misquotation would have no dramatic value and would pass unnoticed by most readers unless Socrates proceeded to correct it [which he did not]. This will be argued in alcibiaxes presently: Taylor, Plato, the Man and his Work London, The presence of this all-important term for Socratic philosophers, defense or apology, should alert the attentive reader to the seriousness of this account.

Dialogues of Plato Socratic dialogues Philosophy book stubs. The reference to young lions e not only recalls the Chorus in the Agamemnon7’2- but the scene in Frogs where Dionysus asks Aeschylus and Euripides what they would do about Alcibiades, and Aeschylus replies that “It were best not to raise a lion cub in the city, but having done so, to indulge his ways.

Socratic dialogue Socratic intellectualism Socratic irony Socratic method Socratic paradox Socratic problem Socratic questioning Socratici viri. One of these was a team of Argive horses said by Plutarch to have belonged to “an Athenian named Diomedes, a respectable person and a friend of Alcibiades, desirous of winning an Olympic victory.

For the rest of the dialogue Socrates explains the many reasons why Alcibiades needs him. This conversation highlights the possible attendant problems associated with a Socratic education in a passage meant to defend Socrates against the charges of corruption:. Although this story is not without problems, Xenophon has fairly persuasively shown that Socrates and Critias were not on favorable terms. That such was probably the intention of Plato’s quotation of Pindar is confirmed by the recent discovery of a papyrus version of the complete ode.

Neither of Apelt’s works are referred to in Untersteiner’s ostensibly comprehensive bibliography n. Alcibiades, on this account, is unfit for philosophy due to a alciibades of many of the requisite virtues.